I try to not spend too much time on Facebook, but when I do make my way over there I am inevitably pulled in by the Reels.
Facebook Reels are terrible, but so interesting. I get a lot of cat content tossed at me (A+) and recently a lot of piano content (also A+, I just love piano nerds). I get some deaf culture content, a lot of Disney World stuff, and some teacher-specific reels.
But you know what I get served up the most? A lot of divorce content. And a lot of invisible labor content. You know what I’m talking about, right? The reels where moms share absolutely horrifying stories of how they asked their husbands to do exactly one thing to contribute to the household and their husband just doesn’t do it? And then argues with them and says that because he’s the one who blows the leaves every fall he really shouldn’t have to be responsible for loading the dishwasher every night. In his mind, this shit is already 50/50.
It’s great content because it’s all very enraging, and makes you think. As I was running up and down the stairs with laundry today I was definitely thinking about the wife who said she no longer does her husband’s laundry. And I frequently think about the woman who wondered what it must be like to be a married man and just always magically have toothpaste and soap at the ready.
I have a weird relationship with this content because of two competing feelings within me.
Feeling #1 – Because I was raised by a single mom, I am eternally grateful for every little thing my husband does. If he didn’t do it, I would have to!
Do you know who paid the bills when I was a kid? My mom. Do you know who shoveled the driveway? My mom. She worked, she bought us new clothes, she took out the trash, she sewed Halloween costumes and bought us books. She fixed broken blinds and broken furniture and broken doors. She signed us up to usher at church, she vacuumed, she went the parent-teacher conferences, she did laundry. She yelled “B is flat! B is flat!” from the kitchen when we were practicing piano while she made dinner.
She. Did. Everything.
In my household there is a husband who does a bunch of stuff. He does 99% of the snow shoveling. He sets up auto-pay for all the bills, manages our money, and deals with our taxes. He did all the research for our new winter tires. I was having trouble with a light switch in the den and he fixed it. He programs and troubleshoots the security system. Now that I am working, he gets the kids off to school every morning. He is currently researching new doorbells. I am so glad I don’t have to research new doorbells.
I am certain that I am still shouldering most of the day-to-day labor load of the household, but I am not doing everything. And I think I am much more satisfied with the status quo in this house because I was raised in a household where the expectation is that the mom does everything. So yeah, am I often grumpy about making dinner every single fucking night? Yes. But I’m also really grateful that I didn’t have to string lights on the Christmas tree, and I haven’t bought plane tickets or made car rental reservations in probably ten years.
I have another friend who was raised by a single mom as well, and I have noticed that she never complains about her husband’s contributions (or lack thereof) to the household.
Expectations and experiences really matter here.
Feeling #2 – I am actually very lazy, don’t really want to be the matriarch of a household, and would prefer to not take care of anyone else ever again.
I don’t want to do all the meal planning and grocery shopping and cooking. I don’t want to deal with summer camp signups and figuring out which camps allow you to wear Crocs and which do not. I am so jealous of my oldest kid who does his own laundry now because he is only doing his own laundry! One load, every Saturday, and he’s done! Meanwhile I am hauling three people’s laundry up and down the stairs twice a week.
I am constantly picking up the house, cleaning up the kitchen, making the bed. I am filled with despair when I picture doing this for the rest of my life. There is a reason I am already yearning for assisted living, and the sweet release of death.
It sometimes feels like to be a woman is to take care of everyone and everything. Is there any relationship in a woman’s life where she doesn’t have to take care of the other person? Whether it’s emotional care or physical care, or just making sure a person has clean underwear and doesn’t miss their bus. Even friends and neighbors require some level of emotional labor: checking in via text, planning get-togethers.
It is unending, and I think women in America are starting to see just how much they are doing and also understand just how much they don’t want to do it.
The problem is that we really can’t opt out of most of it. Someone has to make sure our kids have clean clothes every week and eat a vegetable every once in a while. And unfortunately–at least according to these Facebook Reels that I’m watching–most men are unwilling to step up and be in charge of buying new snowpants for their kids once a year.
I once read somewhere that when you delegate a task to someone else you have to let them take ownership of the whole thing, from beginning to end, and that includes the possibility of failure. How many women are okay putting their husbands in charge of dentist appointments, and then also going to be okay with it when the kids don’t make it to the dentist for several years at a time? How many women are going to be okay with their kids missing the field trip because that permission slip just didn’t get signed? Not many.
The stakes are too high, we cannot allow failure when it comes to our children. Therefore, we will never be able to successfully delegate.
I think this is a huge, legitimate reason why so many women my age and younger are opting out of childbearing. They are opting out from endless caregiving.
I myself am trying to opt out of what I can. I moved a bunch of people off of my gift list and onto my husband’s list. (Taking my own advice about delegation: most of the people on his gifting list are people that I don’t think we need to be giving gifts to anyway, so I don’t mind if he fails.) I announced to my extended family that I would not be cooking Christmas dinner this year and we need to find a place that sells premade Christmas meals. (But now my mom is the one volunteering to find a place that makes premade Christmas meals.)
The problem is this: what happens in twenty years when all the women of the world are opting out of caregiving and kinkeeping? What happens when nobody is willing to step up and plan the family trip to Yellowstone? When there are fewer and fewer children in the world and nobody is willing to helm the spring carnival at their school anyway? What happens when husbands and wives aren’t buying gifts for each other or anyone else?
This invisible labor that we so desperately want to opt out of is so crucial to our human culture. We are already so much more isolated than we used to be. When my grandparents were my age, they went to church on Sunday morning, went to a sibling or friend’s house for coffee in the afternoon, and returned to church for evening service. Someone had to volunteer to hand out bulletins, and someone had to volunteer to host coffee, and someone had to wrangle resentful children into the pews twice that day. It was a lot of work, but they spent the entire day engaged with their family and their community. I spent this Sunday doing laundry and wrapping gifts and watching a Christmas movie on Hulu. I didn’t even text any of my friends.
So when I picture a world where women are freed from their domestic and social labors, I don’t love what I see. I want so badly to opt out, but I hate the consequences. Despite their good intentions, I just don’t think men are going to step up and take on much of what we women drop. And our world will be poorer for it in so many ways.
But I so desperately want to quit meal planning!