Everyone around me is shrinking, and this is starting to feel like an extinction event.
Please give me some grace here as I make some difficult statements that reflect my reality and may not reflect your lived experience.
Everyone around me is shrinking. At first it was just celebrities and influencers. That was hard enough! My very favorite size 18 body-positive influencer went on GLP-1s last year, and although she’s still posting body-positive messages, it’s just not the same when the accompanying photo is of an hourglass size 12 body.
There’s this wonderful poem I love about accepting your body just the way it is and clawing back all the time you’ve spent worrying about your weight and hating yourself. I searched out the poet on the Internet the other day because it had been a couple years since I had followed her. I can’t even describe how betrayed I felt when I discovered that she is also now thin.
There are two local influencers I used to follow back when I was deep into diet culture and striving for weight loss too. They were on the same path, but eventually–like me–gave up ye olde gain/loss/binge/hungry lifestyle to embrace more of a body-neutrality/mindful eating approach. Both of them are now on GLP-1s.
And there are quite a few people in my real life who are on GLP-1s. Some of them I know for sure, and some of them I just know. You can tell. Nobody loses weight that quickly for that many months in a row just with diet and exercise.
It felt for a little bit like culture was moving in the right direction. The idea that obesity wasn’t just a matter of willpower and laziness was gaining momentum. Mindful eating was getting hot. There were pictures of fat women modeling bras at the mall. The Health at Any Size movement was winning ground, even in doctor’s offices. Plus size hiking pants were a thing!
For the first time in my life, I felt like maybe my body was okay? Maybe I was okay? Maybe my body really wasn’t the problem all along?
And then GLP-1s became widely available, and all of this cultural and personal change has come to a crashing halt.
Let me be clear: I think GLP-1s are actually a good thing. There is no question that they are improving the health of millions of Americans. For many people, they are truly a miracle. On an individual level, I am very supportive of GLP-1s. Those influencers I mention above did not owe it to me or to anyone else to stay fat.
It’s the cultural effect of GLP-1s that is causing me great despair. The fewer of us fat people there are, the less inclusive the world will be. Why use a fat woman to sell bras when your customer base is now mostly in the normal BMI range? Why make walking pads that can support someone who weighs more than 250 lbs when almost nobody weighs that much anymore? Why deal with your patient’s body dysmorphia and slightly elevated blood pressure holistically when you can just write a prescription instead?
“Your body is not the problem,” one of those fat-positive influencers used to say all the time. But as soon as she was given a non-surgical option to become thin, she took it.
If she can’t accept her body just the way it is, what hope does a normal, not-fashionable, not-confident person like me have?
And if the people I love the most assure me that my body is just fine the way it is, but then they choose to go and shrink their own bodies, how am I supposed to interpret that?
I know that what other people do with their own bodies is not a reflection on my body. I know that. But also… isn’t it? We are social creatures. Our lives are always tangled up in cultural norms. Everyone else starts watching Bridgerton so we do to. Everyone else is wearing skinny jeans so we do too. (Remember how ridiculous those looked at first?)
What is it going to be like for those of us who are still out here trying to just live our lives as fat people? It seems like there will be this strange sub-class of humans who either don’t want to take GLP-1s, don’t have access to GLP-1s, or can’t take GLP-1s for medical/side effect reasons. There will always be obese people in the nation, but I’m not sure how many there will be in the end. And I suspect the world won’t be kind to us.
“Your body is not the problem.” I still say it to myself, whisper it like a prayer, but it doesn’t feel possible to believe it anymore. I think GLP-1s may be proving that it was never really possible.
So where do I go from here?